Uploaded image for project: 'Qt'
  1. Qt
  2. QTBUG-130322

QAudioSink does not play audio on Ubuntu 22.04 when started with a large buffer

    XMLWordPrintable

Details

    • Bug
    • Resolution: Unresolved
    • P2: Important
    • None
    • 6.8.0
    • Multimedia
    • As seen in Calibre 7.20 TTS, Ubuntu 22.04, X11 and reproduced with PySide
    • Linux/X11

    Description

      This is a reproduction of a problem seen using Calibre 7.20 TTS on Ubuntu 22.04.

       

      When a QAudioSink is initialised with a large buffer, it does not play the audio it reads from a custom QIODevice if the QIODevice initially starts empty.

       

      The attached PySide script incrementally generates sound data and signals the QAudioSink when there is more to read. It has command line parameters to start with/without an initially empty QIODevice and set the buffer size.

       

      We see a different pattern of calls on the custom QIODevice when it works and when it does not.

      a) When it fails, the QAudioSink only calls QIODevice.atEnd once and does not transition from Active to Idle after each sound clip has been read.

      b) We also see inconsistent calls to QIODevice.readData between the different cases. If using the default buffer size,  QIODevice.readData never gets called with a zero length (which the docs say is to allow for cleanup activity)

       

      There are three main cases of interest:

       

      1. bug reproduction - start empty but with large buffer -> no sound

       

      python audio_test.py --start_empty 2097152

      starting with buffer_size=2097152, start_empty=True
        config: start QIODevice without data
        config: Use QAudioSink buffer size  2097152
      QIODevice.isSequential
      QIODevice.bytesAvailable 0
      QAudioSink.state = ActiveState
      QIODevice.readData -returned 0 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.atEnd True
        – generate data --
      QIODevice.readData -returned 16384 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.readData -returned 10076 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.readData - Zero length requested
      QIODevice.readData -returned 0 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.atEnd True
        – generate data --
      QIODevice.readData -returned 16384 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.readData -returned 10076 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.readData - Zero length requested
      QIODevice.readData -returned 0 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.atEnd True
        – generate data --
      QIODevice.readData -returned 16384 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.readData -returned 10076 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.readData - Zero length requested
      QIODevice.readData -returned 0 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.atEnd True

       

      2. workaround - use a large buffer but ensure data is ready before QAudioSink.start -> makes sound

      python audio_test.py 2097152

      starting with buffer_size=2097152, start_empty=False
        config: start QIODevice with data ready
        config: Use QAudioSink buffer size  2097152
      QIODevice.isSequential
      QIODevice.bytesAvailable 26460
      QAudioSink.state = ActiveState
      QIODevice.readData -returned 16384 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.readData -returned 10076 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.readData - Zero length requested
      QIODevice.readData -returned 0 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.atEnd True
      QIODevice.atEnd True
      QAudioSink.state = IdleState
        – generate data --
      QIODevice.readData -returned 16384 bytes maxlen=16384
      QAudioSink.state = ActiveState
      QIODevice.readData -returned 10076 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.readData - Zero length requested
      QIODevice.readData -returned 0 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.atEnd True
      QIODevice.atEnd True
      QAudioSink.state = IdleState
        – generate data --
      QIODevice.readData -returned 16384 bytes maxlen=16384
      QAudioSink.state = ActiveState
      QIODevice.readData -returned 10076 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.readData - Zero length requested
      QIODevice.readData -returned 0 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.atEnd True
      QIODevice.atEnd True
      QAudioSink.state = IdleState

       

      3. workaround - start empty but don't set a buffer size and just use default -> makes sound

      python audio_test.py --start_empty 0

      starting with buffer_size=0, start_empty=True
        config: start QIODevice without data
        config: Use default QAudioSink buffer size 8820
      QIODevice.isSequential
      QIODevice.bytesAvailable 0
      QAudioSink.state = ActiveState
      QIODevice.readData -returned 0 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.atEnd True
        – generate data --
      QIODevice.readData -returned 16384 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.readData -returned 10076 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.readData -returned 0 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.readData -returned 0 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.atEnd True
      QIODevice.atEnd True
      QAudioSink.state = IdleState
        – generate data --
      QIODevice.readData -returned 16384 bytes maxlen=16384
      QAudioSink.state = ActiveState
      QIODevice.readData -returned 10076 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.readData -returned 0 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.readData -returned 0 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.atEnd True
      QIODevice.atEnd True
      QAudioSink.state = IdleState
        – generate data --
      QIODevice.readData -returned 16384 bytes maxlen=16384
      QAudioSink.state = ActiveState
      QIODevice.readData -returned 10076 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.readData -returned 0 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.readData -returned 0 bytes maxlen=16384
      QIODevice.atEnd True
      QIODevice.atEnd True
      QAudioSink.state = IdleState

      Attachments

        1. audio_test.py
          7 kB
          Duncan Woods
        No reviews matched the request. Check your Options in the drop-down menu of this sections header.

        Activity

          People

            qtmultimediateam Qt Multimedia Team
            dawdaw Duncan Woods
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            1 Start watching this issue

            Dates

              Created:
              Updated:

              Gerrit Reviews

                There are no open Gerrit changes