right click menu far too high on OSX Mavericks when using multiscreen

When using multiple screens in Mavericks, right clicking puts the menu far too high. In the first attachment, for example, I right clicked on line 60 (highest resolution "most space"). In the third attachment, I right clicked on line 63 (Normal resolution "Best for retina display"). I am guessing that it is calculating the position of the menu based on the total height of all stacked screens, as the behaviour changes if I change the screen resolution. See my setup in attachment 2. The laptop is the bottom left screen.